Thinking about voting soon, I came across Denis Haack’sblog, which is associated with their magazine, Critique, published by Ransom Fellowship. (As a side note, both Critique and Notes from Toad Hall are distributed for free — of course RF needs donations to survive — but the short magazines are really amazing for Christians developing engagement and discernment with our cultures. Go sign up!)
Back to the topic at hand: Denis Haack recently posted an insightful article by James Skillen. From Denis: “His theme: “Taking Citizenship Seriously: Christian Responsibility in Today’s Political Context.” The three talks were certainly appropriate for this election year, without veering off into topics that appropriate for only this particular election. Skillen, the president of the Center for Public Justice, has spent a lifetime reflecting biblically on Christian faithfulness in the politics and citizenship.” The article can be read in its entirety here.
Denis’ most recent post is in response to a woman sharing this article mentioned above with her friends as a way to stimulate dialogue. Sadly the friends thought the article entirely one-sided and so she wrote to Denis to ask his advice about how to deal with this mess. One part of his reply I find particularly helpful:
First, many Christians have come to believe that conformity is a measure of commitment—in other words, that believers should necessarily share not just identical doctriness and ethics, but opinions and activities. However, having a Christian mind does not mean that there is a “Christian line” on every topic. Life and reality are far richer and more nuanced than that. Second, many evangelicals, having decided that a conservative ideology embraces their political leanings, begin to confuse conservatism with Christianity. It’s a subtle process, but also a deadly one, since no ideology should be infused into the gospel. Third, few understand that political ideologies are not neutral, but are, to use a biblical theological category, idolatries. Each one, conservatism included, takes one aspect of created reality and elevates it to a position where it defines the rest of life—making it into a god, a sovereign.
Yes, it is widely the case that the Evangelical Christian world has associated conservatism with Christianity, while of course there is a whole new generation of Evangelicals — if they even call themselves that — who as a friend has recently posted about (here and here), are voting without reference to standard “Evangelical” issues such as abortion but instead voting Democratic as it (at least on its platform) aids the voiceless in our society.
It’s a muddy soup and frankly I’m still not exactly sure who will get my vote on the 4th. But if you are a Christian, I ask that you would take a step back from your record of voting and consider if you’ve fused liberalism or conservatism into the gospel. Because if you believe that and act like Jesus is King it really doesn’t matter who becomes President.*
(Also, for further reading, Bryce has recently posted a quote from John Piper about voting here as well as including the link to the entire article.)
*I do have to add that yes, it matters and has consequences, but it shouldn’t define us.