Breastfeeding in the Public Sphere
First off, let me say that breastfeeding your children — even in the US — puts you into a camp. My previous-before-children-self liked to wear high heels and talk about literature (don’t worry, that self is still in here somewhere…) while the child-bearing mama is lucky to get any makeup on and shoes that require tying are pretty much too much hassle. But back to breastfeeding. Breastfeeding, though, can seem to put one automatically into the “crunchy granola” category, especially if you do it in public (I do) and especially if you nurse your children longer than one year (I do). You see breastfeeding, or seeing someone breastfeed, tends to weird out our no-nonsense-upwardly-mobile culture. It brings us back to our roots. It’s primal. And it reminds us that humanity is intensely physical rather than purely cerebral. So it’s a weird mix for me personally as I neither fully embrace the business-savvy world of the high-heeled suit-wearing throngs and neither do I fully fit in the herb-tastic nature-mother cohort. Trying to mix the two worlds has its challenges.
When I was working as a college professor during Ezra’s first year of life, the administration graciously gave me classes solely on two days a week so that I could work from home and take care of my son the other three days a week. On my two “work” days, Ezra took bottles of expressed milk from Bryce (on his “day off”) one day and from my mom the other day. My mom would drive to campus and watch Ezra while I taught and hand him off to me during my prep times. Let me say I was so glad I could pump, but it was a bit insane. I’d rush back from a class, stacks of books in my hands, slam shut my office door, strap on my pumping paraphernalia and pump straight for the 15-minutes I’d have between classes. Sometimes I could do this while looking over notes for the following class and praying that I wouldn’t leak all over my fancy work clothes. It was an odd juxtaposition: working lactating mother.
My own experience has lead me to consider how our society views breastfeeding mothers. What disturbs me the most is those who consider it unnatural or weird, that view breasts as only instruments of sexual arousal rather than as sources of nourishment and comfort. Consider one example: an article in The Gospel and Culture Project, “Is the Church Threatened by Breastfeeding?“, discusses the need for the Church (as one institution) to promote breastfeeding rather than sexualizing a normal experience.
That moment of anxiety in the pew stands as a metonym for all the ways in which our culture objectifies, commodifies and exploits women’s bodies for sexual pleasure and financial gain. The church that is afraid of breastfeeding has allowed culture to dictate the meaning of female sexuality.
I’ve quoted the final paragraph before on this blog, but it bears repeating:
Perhaps there is no better reason for churches to encourage nursing than for the mother herself, enabling her to integrate the physical with the spiritual, and the ordinary with the transcendent. It may be the only time all week she can slow down and listen to God. We need her, but she needs us even more.
If you breastfeed, what have your experiences been nursing in public? How do we get American culture to value the breastfeeding mother?
August 4th, 2009 at 1:22 pm
Great post Ashley,
My limited observations of breastfeeding women here in the USA so far (and they’ve been restricted to churchgoing women) has been that they are much less inclined to do it in public than in the UK.
In our London church many of the breastfeeding mothers would happily feed in the pew and manage to do it discreetly and without anyone noticing. I don’t think anyone feeds in the pew here and all of the mothers I’ve seen feeding (even in the company of other women) do it with some kind of blanket or cloth draped over themselves.
August 4th, 2009 at 1:30 pm
I don’t know if I have my head in a hole, but I think breastfeeding is highly valued (at least among our generation), but I think it has it’s limits as you mentioned, i.e. nurse for the first year and public discretion. I have nursed Charlotte while attending a church service. I don’t know what people around me thought??? I haven’t put much thought into it. I know I have seen some women fully exposed while nursing, but I prefer a little privacy personally. To each their own. I do appreciate that you have continued to nurse Ezra despite the social stigma. I think I feel less inclined to do what everyone else is doing or what the books say to do this time around and to do what I feel is best suited for me as the Mom God has designed me to be and the children He has given me. Motherhood is not a science, for heaven’s sake. Thanks for sharing and for feeling the freedom you feel to do what you feel is best! Those boys of yours have a great Mama!
August 5th, 2009 at 2:36 pm
I love reading your thoughts on this and truly appreciate them!! Thanks for posting, Ashley! Makes me miss you and sooo wish you were still back down in San Diego (wish we could have hung out more!).
August 5th, 2009 at 5:18 pm
hi ashley!! long time!! thought i’d drop a hello on your blog. =) i work with predominantly hispanic women, and breastfeeding is a common thing. lately, breastfeeding has actually become the trend again so i personally haven’t felt any negative stereotypes or perceptions. if anything, i feel like there is even a quasi-competitive nature that has developed with breastfeeding in the upper socioeconomic class as an opposite judgement is made — you must not care enough about what’s best for your baby since you’ve chosen to start formula, etc. it’s an interesting dynamic as you look at the different cultural, educational, and social backgrounds and how they contribute to the perception of breastfeeding. i for one love breastfeeding because it is free milk! i am a huge fan of anything free, in addition to all the other benefits. =)
August 11th, 2009 at 7:23 am
Hi Ash! I love reading your thoughts and agree with them. I also think that society’s/US’s view of breastfeeding has gotten better over the past 10-20 years, from what I’ve been told by mothers with older kids.
I breastfeed in public but realize that it does make some people uncomfortable, so I use a cover if I’m out somewhere like a mall. Of course, now Levi hates the cover because he isn’t used to it, so it’s becoming a problem.
I just took a cross-country trip with Levi and nursed him several times on the flights, which was a feat considering the cramped space and his aversion to the cover. I used the sling to partially cover his head and that seemed to work.