Paper Doll Politics
Posted by Ashley on July 9th, 2005As you all know, the G8 Summit is being held here in Scotland and while we were away we missed the opportunity to march in the Make Poverty History protest which was intended to communicate to the world’s most powerful leaders that we supported a full relief of aid-associated debt and that they had the opportunity to actually make poverty history, especially in poor African countries. You also are aware of the recent terrorist attacks in London. Tony Blair flew down from the G8 Summit in Gleneagles to London to make a statement in words which sounded a whole lot like Bush’s speeches after 9/11 — vagueries about freedom and not letting terrorists prevail. I imagine the vagueries are really all that is rhetorically possible, when the government isn’t even sure who or how this happened and has no way to stopping suicide bombings as it deviates from conventional warfare. It does make me think if the world is headed for some WWIII of video game warfare without any recognisable fronts or fighting. But I digress.
We were having a discussion with the Hays last night about fair trade coffee and the ridiculousness of Starbucks having a fair trade option to chose from; as we agreed, if you’re serious about fair trade issues, than make all your coffee fair trade, not just having one option so you appear socially aware and responsible. With the Make Poverty History campaign, I do wonder how much of our ecological-friendly or fair trade buying habits are simply now reactionary, where we are paper dolls who happen to put on the fair trade outfit over our naked selves because it’s what’s the new hip now. And I’m as guilty as the rest. I admit I proudly wore my “Make Poverty History” white band during the conference in Greece and felt pretty cool wearing it, which is completely inane. Buying free range or fair trade has become yet another gold star on my “do-good” chart. Granted, I do think it is our responsibility, indeed a necessity, to buy free range and fair trade products not just because it’s the politically saavy thing to do, but because as Christians we have a responsibility to care for the very least of these — (Jesus said “the poor you will always have with you”; how much do we take this to heart?) which includes seeking to reward business practices that put global ethical responsibility above their aspirations for a huge profit margin.
This, like all “good deeds”, is but filthy rags, a slick new piece of paper which hides our nakedness underneath. We are at bottom sinners, whether this is manifested in deviance or whitewashed moralism. If Christ alone is Truth, as we believe as Christians, than our lives need to emulate this Truth — not because it’s the “right” or “moral” or “proper” thing to do, but because as we are transformed into Christ’s likeness, our lives in turn (including our buying habits) need to be transformed. It’s time we got specific and didn’t settle for pat answers, emotional rhetoric from politicians, or buying fair trade because it makes us feel good about ourselves. If you’re a Christian, you are called to pick up your cross and deny yourself. That may mean not eating meat because of factory farming — or at least buying free range chicken. That may mean you sacrifice your time, money and reputation so that others can have more than you. That may mean you live in a small house so that you can give more of your income to the poor around you or those who do not even have running water or enough food for today. That may mean researching where your food comes from and who sources it so that you are making decisions for more than your immediate desires for brand name washing up liquid. Christianity has never been about being comfortable or following rules. It has always been about Jesus, Jesus who gave himself up for us who never could deserve it. I imagine I shall return again to this topic and so will provide some links to research I’ve found then. For now, I leave you with a portion of a Derek Webb song.
i repent, i repent of my pursuit of america’s dream
i repent, i repent of living like i deserve anything
of my house, my fence, my kids, my wife
in our suburb where we’re safe and white
i am wrong and of these things i repent
i repent, i repent of parading my liberty
i repent. i repent of paying for what i get for free
and for the way i believe that i am living right
by trading sins for others that are easier to hide
i am wrong and of these things i repent